El sofisma de Martin

Bruno Moreno of InfoCatólica criticized Father James Martin, SJ, accusing the American Jesuit of using ambiguity to defend LGBT ideology while avoiding Church sanctions.

Moreno claims that Martin has spent years undermining Church doctrine regarding same-sex relationships by using a method of implying rather than stating his positions directly. The report suggests this approach allows Martin to maintain plausible deniability, ensuring he can claim he did not say what his words appeared to convey. According to Moreno, the Jesuit order rewarded Martin by appointing him to lead América, the primary Jesuit magazine in the United States.